This topic has been archived. It cannot be replied.
工作学习 / 外语学习 / 各位，请教个及其基础简单的语法问题（现在完成时和一般过去时的区别），请勿鄙视啊，这两句，表达的意思有什么不同？
She has led an illustrious life. 和 He led an illustrious life. 是不是还在世的用has led，而不在世的用led？谢谢了。
-starrystarrynight(StarryNight);
2018-4-2(#11456124@0)
This very hard explain. If you live in english environment enough long, you can know these two expressions not same.
-oknplm(oknplm);
2018-4-2(#11457544@0)
TA's life was good. TA's life is bad.
-troyd(|);
2018-4-2(#11457816@0)
就是说这种情况就不适合用has led了，对吗？比如改成She led an illustrious life. She lead a bad life now. 对吗？但是看到这句，She led an illustrious life. 会不会让人误解是在描述去世的人？
-starrystarrynight(StarryNight);
2018-4-2(#11457819@0)
可以这样说：He used to have a good life (good life in the past),
-chubbypanda(三下五除二);
2018-4-3{196}(#11458008@0)
but he no longer does now (bad life at present). 你如果用has led a good life, 大家会以为这种状态还会持续到将来 (good life in the past, good life at the present, probably good life in the future)。